Skip to content

Student page · Class 11–12 Commerce

Project: a fair comparison of two companies

You will compare two companies from the same industry, fairly. Use your pair card, the two receipts and one annual report. Every number needs its year and its filing.

For learning only. Cityfort is not a SEBI-registered adviser and does not recommend buying or selling any security. Prices shown are dated and may be out of date.

What to do

  1. Choose one pair. Read its card and its two receipts.
  2. Work out the change in revenue and in net profit from FY25 to FY26 for both companies.
  3. Work out the net profit ratio for both companies in both years.
  4. Compare two receipt lines, and find your pair's trap.
  5. Find one more fact in an annual report, with its page.
  6. Write your fair comparison. No verdict, no ranking.

Pair 1. Hindustan Unilever and ITC

Both sell everyday goods, mostly in India: home care, beauty, personal care and foods at HUL; cigarettes, foods, farm goods and paperboard at ITC. Both use the April–March year; numbers are consolidated.

  • Hindustan Unilever: revenue from operations ₹61,328 crore in FY25 and ₹64,468 crore in FY26; net profit ₹10,649 crore in FY25 and ₹15,040 crore in FY26.
  • ITC: revenue from operations ₹81,613 crore in FY25 and ₹89,913 crore in FY26; net profit ₹34,747 crore in FY25 and ₹20,689 crore in FY26.
  • HUL's FY26 profit includes a one-off gain of ₹4,611 crore on demerging its ice cream business; profit of the business it kept was ₹10,633 crore.
  • ITC's FY25 profit includes ₹15,016 crore from the demerged hotels business, mainly a one-off demerger gain; FY25 continuing profit was ₹19,731 crore.
  • ITC's receipt has an excise duty line: a tax charged on goods made, which ITC pays out of what customers pay it.
  • Filings: Hindustan Unilever's FY26 annual report and ITC's FY26 annual report, both on NSE.

Pair 2. DMart and Trent

Both run shops: DMart sells groceries and household goods; Trent sells its own-brand clothes, footwear and beauty products in its own stores. Both use the April–March year; numbers are consolidated.

  • DMart: revenue from operations ₹59,358 crore in FY25 and ₹68,821 crore in FY26; net profit ₹2,708 crore in FY25 and ₹2,970 crore in FY26.
  • Trent: revenue from operations ₹17,135 crore in FY25 and ₹20,074 crore in FY26; net profit ₹1,547 crore in FY25 and ₹1,720 crore in FY26.
  • DMart owns most of its store buildings: 68 of its 500 stores were in leased buildings in FY26.
  • Trent books store leases as right-of-use assets and lease liabilities (Ind AS 116). As a result, much of its rent shows as depreciation and interest; some sits in store occupancy.
  • The DMart stores company alone made ₹3,224 crore of profit in FY26; DMart Ready, a subsidiary, lost ₹307 crore.
  • Filings: DMart's FY26 annual report and Trent's FY26 annual report, both on NSE.

Pair 3. Infosys and TCS

Both sell software and technology services, mostly to companies abroad. Both use the April–March year; numbers are consolidated.

  • Infosys: revenue from operations ₹1,62,990 crore in FY25 and ₹1,78,650 crore in FY26; net profit ₹26,713 crore in FY25 and ₹29,440 crore in FY26.
  • TCS: revenue from operations ₹2,55,324 crore in FY25 and ₹2,67,021 crore in FY26; net profit ₹48,553 crore in FY25 and ₹49,210 crore in FY26.
  • The two receipts group their lines differently: Infosys puts lease interest, tax and a one-off charge in one line (₹6.7 of each ₹100); TCS shows interest and tax (₹6.4) and one-off charges (₹1.7) separately.
  • Infosys's Q3 FY26 includes a one-off charge of ₹1,289 crore before tax.
  • Filings: Infosys's FY26 annual report and TCS's FY26 annual report, both on NSE.

Pair 4. HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank

Both are private banks: they take deposits and lend. Both use the April–March year. Their yearly numbers are consolidated (the whole group); their receipts are for each bank alone.

  • HDFC Bank: total income ₹4,70,916 crore in FY25 and ₹4,95,463 crore in FY26; net profit ₹70,792 crore in FY25 and ₹76,026 crore in FY26.
  • ICICI Bank: total income ₹2,94,587 crore in FY25 and ₹3,12,118 crore in FY26; net profit ₹51,029 crore in FY25 and ₹54,208 crore in FY26.
  • HDFC Bank's group total income includes the insurance income of HDFC Life and HDFC ERGO, part of the group since FY24. ICICI Bank's includes ICICI Prudential Life's insurance income and, since 29 Feb 2024, ICICI Lombard's.
  • Kept as profit, bank alone: HDFC Bank ₹20.2 and ICICI Bank ₹25.0 of each ₹100. Group net profit ratio in FY26: HDFC Bank 15.3%, ICICI Bank 17.4%.
  • Filings: HDFC Bank's FY26 annual report and ICICI Bank's FY26 annual report, both on NSE.

The receipts

Where each ₹100 went: Hindustan Unilever, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Materials and goods bought₹48.6
Advertising and promotion₹9.6
Other running costs, incl. fees to Unilever₹12.7
Employees₹4.9
Depreciation, interest and net one-off charges₹3.1
Tax₹4.8
Kept as profit for HUL shareholders₹16.3
Total₹100.0

Source: Hindustan Unilever's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 2 Jun 2026; consolidated statement of profit and loss, continuing business (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ revenue plus other income × 100).

Where each ₹100 went: ITC, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Materials and goods bought₹35.1
Excise duty₹11.9
Other running costs₹13.2
Employee costs₹7.3
Depreciation, interest, one-offs and minority share₹2.6
Income tax₹7.6
Kept as profit for ITC shareholders₹22.3
Total₹100.0

Source: ITC's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 26 Jun 2026; consolidated statement of profit and loss (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ revenue, other income and share of part-owned companies' profit × 100).

Where each ₹100 went: DMart, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Goods bought for sale₹84.9
Employees₹2.2
Other running costs₹5.3
Depreciation₹1.5
Interest₹0.2
Income tax₹1.6
Kept as profit for shareholders₹4.3
Total₹100.0

Source: DMart's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 23 Jul 2026; consolidated results for the year (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ revenue plus other income × 100).

Where each ₹100 went: Trent, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Goods bought for resale₹55.8
Store occupancy, including some rent₹7.7
Other running costs₹11.0
Employees₹6.7
Depreciation, interest and one-offs₹7.7
Income tax₹2.6
Kept as profit for Trent shareholders₹8.5
Total₹100.0

Source: Trent's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 30 May 2026; consolidated statement of profit and loss (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ revenue plus other income × 100).

Where each ₹100 went: Infosys, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Employees₹52.0
Subcontractors₹8.4
Software packages and bought-in items₹8.6
Travel, communication and other costs₹5.5
Depreciation₹2.7
Lease interest, tax and one-off charge₹6.7
Kept as profit₹16.1
Total₹100.0

Source: Infosys's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 30 May 2026; consolidated statement of profit and loss (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ revenue plus other income × 100).

Where each ₹100 went: TCS, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Staff pay and benefits₹57.1
Outside consultants (subcontractors)₹5.4
Offices, travel, resold hardware and other costs₹9.2
Depreciation₹2.0
Interest and tax₹6.4
One-off charges₹1.7
Kept as profit for TCS shareholders₹18.1
Profit belonging to minority partners₹0.1
Total₹100.0

Source: TCS's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 15 May 2026; consolidated statement of profit and loss (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ revenue plus other income × 100).

Where each ₹100 went: HDFC Bank, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Interest paid to depositors₹37.4
Interest paid on borrowings₹10.9
Employees₹7.0
Other running costs₹12.6
Provisions for bad loans and other risks₹6.3
Tax₹5.5
Kept as profit₹20.2
Total₹99.9

Source: HDFC Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 11 Jul 2026; standalone profit and loss account, HDFC Bank alone (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ interest earned plus other income × 100). Lines are rounded to the nearest 10 paise, so the total may differ from ₹100 by a few paise.

Where each ₹100 went: ICICI Bank, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Interest paid to depositors and lenders₹40.8
Employees₹9.0
Other running costs₹14.6
Provisions for bad loans and other risks₹2.7
Tax₹8.0
Kept as profit₹25.0
Total₹100.1

Source: ICICI Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 18 Jul 2026; standalone profit and loss account, ICICI Bank alone (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ interest earned plus other income × 100). Lines are rounded to the nearest 10 paise, so the total may differ from ₹100 by a few paise.

Questions

  1. Which pair did you choose? What are both companies' financial years, and are the numbers standalone or consolidated?
  2. What is the trap in your pair, and how does it change one of your results?
  3. Which difference between the two companies did you explain, and what reason did you give?
  4. What can your two aspects not tell you about either company?

Word bank

Comparative statement:
Two years side by side, with the change in rupees and in per cent.
Common-size statement:
Every line as a share of one base, here ₹100 of money that came in.
Net profit ratio:
Net profit ÷ revenue from operations × 100. For a bank, divide by total income.
One-off item:
A gain or cost that happens once, such as a gain on a demerger. It can make one year look very different.
Total income:
What a bank reports instead of revenue: interest earned plus other income.
Verdict:
A judgement on which company is ahead or worth owning. A fair comparison has none.

Sentence starters

  • From FY25 to FY26, ___'s revenue changed by ___% and ___'s by ___%.
  • ___ spent ₹___ of every ₹100 on ___, and ___ spent ₹___, because ___.
  • My pair's trap is ___; without it, the result would be ___.
  • My comparison cannot show ___.

Data from Hindustan Unilever's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 2 Jun 2026; ITC's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 26 Jun 2026; DMart's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 23 Jul 2026; Trent's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 30 May 2026; Infosys's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 30 May 2026; TCS's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 15 May 2026; HDFC Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 11 Jul 2026; ICICI Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 18 Jul 2026; Hyundai Motor India's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 3 Aug 2026; and Maruti Suzuki's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 8 Aug 2026. Checked 15 Nov 2026.