Student page · Class 11–12 Commerce
Four traps that make a comparison unfair
Two numbers can look comparable and still not be. Your group gets one station card with one trap. Find it, then rewrite an unfair sentence so it is fair.
What to do
- Write one check in Part A before your group starts.
- Read your station card. Every number you need is on it.
- Answer your station's questions and rewrite its unfair sentence.
- Teach your trap to the class, and note the other groups' traps in Part F.
Station 1. Standalone or consolidated? DMart, FY26
Avenue Supermarts runs the DMart stores. It also owns subsidiaries, including Avenue E-Commerce, which runs the DMart Ready delivery service.
- Profit of the DMart stores company alone (standalone): ₹3,224 crore
- Profit of the whole group for shareholders (consolidated): ₹2,970 crore
- Loss of Avenue E-Commerce (DMart Ready): ₹307 crore
- Unfair sentence: "DMart made more profit in FY26 than its consolidated accounts show."
- Filing: DMart's FY26 annual report on NSE.
Station 2. Different calendars: ABB India and Hitachi Energy India
Both companies make electrical equipment for power grids and factories, and both report standalone figures. ABB India's year runs January to December. Hitachi Energy India's runs April to March.
- ABB India, CY25 (January to December 2025): revenue ₹13,203 crore
- Hitachi Energy India, FY26 (April 2025 to March 2026): revenue ₹8,148 crore
- ABB India, quarter by quarter: April–June 2025 ₹3,175 crore; July–September ₹3,311 crore; October–December ₹3,557 crore
- Hitachi Energy India, quarter by quarter: April–June 2025 ₹1,479 crore; July–September ₹1,833 crore; October–December ₹2,082 crore
- ABB calls April–June 2025 its Q2 CY25. Hitachi calls the same months its Q1 FY26.
- Unfair sentence: "In the same year, ABB India's revenue was about 1.6 times Hitachi Energy India's."
Station 3. A demerger: Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles
On 1 Oct 2025 Tata Motors split off its trucks and buses business into a separate company. The company that stayed, Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles, kept cars, electric cars and Jaguar Land Rover (JLR).
- FY25 revenue as first reported in the FY25 annual report, with trucks and buses: ₹4,39,695 crore
- FY25 revenue re-presented in the FY26 annual report, without trucks and buses: ₹3,66,094 crore
- FY26 revenue, without trucks and buses: ₹3,35,582 crore
- FY26 reported profit for owners: ₹82,390 crore, which includes a one-off demerger gain of ₹82,616 crore that brought in no cash. The continuing business's profit for owners: ₹19,075 crore in FY25 and −₹1,632 crore in FY26.
- Unfair sentence: "Revenue fell -23.7% in FY26."
- Filing: the FY26 annual report on NSE.
Station 4. A bank and a carmaker: HDFC Bank and Maruti Suzuki, FY26
Read the two ₹100 receipts below. HDFC Bank's receipt is for the bank alone (standalone); Maruti Suzuki's is consolidated.
- HDFC Bank's money in: interest earned on loans and investments ₹3,07,522 crore, plus other income ₹62,533 crore
- HDFC Bank on 31 Mar 2026: loans given (advances) ₹29,37,166 crore; deposits ₹31,05,250 crore
- HDFC Bank's own measures for FY26: net interest margin 3.34%; gross bad loans (NPAs) 1.15% of loans
- Maruti Suzuki's EBITDA (profit before interest, tax and depreciation) was 11.7% of revenue. A bank reports no EBITDA.
- Unfair sentence: "HDFC Bank kept ₹20.2 of every ₹100 and Maruti only ₹7.8, so the bank runs its business with more control over costs."
The receipts
| Line | Per ₹100 that came in |
|---|---|
| Interest paid to depositors | ₹37.4 |
| Interest paid on borrowings | ₹10.9 |
| Employees | ₹7.0 |
| Other running costs | ₹12.6 |
| Provisions for bad loans and other risks | ₹6.3 |
| Tax | ₹5.5 |
| Kept as profit | ₹20.2 |
| Total | ₹99.9 |
Source: HDFC Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 11 Jul 2026; standalone profit and loss account, HDFC Bank alone (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ interest earned plus other income × 100). Lines are rounded to the nearest 10 paise, so the total may differ from ₹100 by a few paise.
| Line | Per ₹100 that came in |
|---|---|
| Materials, parts and goods bought | ₹70.5 |
| Employees | ₹4.8 |
| Royalty to Suzuki Motor Corporation | ₹2.9 |
| Other running costs | ₹7.9 |
| Depreciation and interest | ₹3.7 |
| Income tax | ₹2.4 |
| Kept as profit | ₹7.8 |
| Total | ₹100.0 |
Source: Maruti Suzuki's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 8 Aug 2026; consolidated statement of profit and loss (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ revenue, other income and share of part-owned companies' profit × 100).
Questions
- Which trap did your station show? Which rule does it break?
- Write your station's unfair sentence, then your fair version.
- Which other group's trap would you be most likely to miss? Why?
Word bank
- Standalone:
- The statements of the listed company alone, without its subsidiaries.
- Consolidated:
- The statements of the whole group: the company and its subsidiaries together.
- Calendar year (CY):
- A year from January to December. CY25 is January to December 2025.
- Demerger:
- When a company splits off part of its business into a separate company.
- Re-presented:
- Last year's numbers shown again, without the business that left, so both years cover the same business.
- Advances:
- The loans a bank has given out.
Sentence starters
- This comparison breaks the rule ___ because ___.
- A fair version is: In ___, ___ was ₹___ crore and ___ was ₹___ crore, both ___.
- Before comparing, I would check ___.
Data from DMart's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 23 Jul 2026; ABB India's CY25 annual report, filed with NSE on 9 Apr 2026; Hitachi Energy India's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 31 Jul 2026; Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 15 Jun 2026; HDFC Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 11 Jul 2026; and Maruti Suzuki's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 8 Aug 2026. Checked 15 Nov 2026.