Skip to content
New: 30 more Indian companies explained, from Ather and Pine Labs to IDBI Bank

Lesson 4 · 40 minutes · Class 11–12 Commerce

Reading a credit rating report: what Crisil, CARE and ICRA wrote about three companies

Reading a credit rating report is a free 40-minute lesson for Class 11–12 Commerce on how agencies rate company debt. Students read three published rating reports, on HUL, NTPC and JSW Energy, and record each rating, its reasons and what could change it.

For learning only. Cityfort is not a SEBI-registered adviser and does not recommend buying or selling any security. Prices shown are dated and may be out of date.

Class
Senior secondary, Class 11–12 (Commerce)
Time
One 40-minute period, run as a jigsaw in groups of three.
Formats
Web page, student page, teacher guide (PDF), worksheet with exit ticket (PDF), answer key (PDF), slides (PowerPoint)
Companies
Hindustan Unilever, NTPC, JSW Energy
Data
Data from Hindustan Unilever's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 2 Jun 2026; NTPC's Q2 FY27 quarterly results, filed with BSE on 31 Oct 2026; and JSW Energy's Q2 FY27 quarterly results, filed with NSE on 28 Oct 2026. Checked 16 Nov 2026.
Edition
2026–27 first edition, v1.0
License
Free under CC BY-NC 4.0. No student logins.

Students start with a puzzle. HUL had ₹0 crore of borrowings on 31 Mar 2026, and NTPC had ₹2,75,634 crore on 30 Sep 2026. Yet Crisil rated HUL AAA/Stable on 3 Oct 2025, and CARE rated NTPC CARE AAA; Stable on 22 May 2026.

In a jigsaw, each student in a group of three reads one rating report: Crisil on HUL, CARE on NTPC or ICRA on JSW Energy. They fill a rating card, then teach their group what their agency watches and what could change the rating.

What's included?

Student page (no login, no answers)

cityfort.in/teachers/debt-cash-and-staying-power/reading-a-credit-rating/student

Short link for the board: cityfort.in/class/credit-rating

Share with a class or a colleague

https://cityfort.in/teachers/debt-cash-and-staying-power/reading-a-credit-rating

What will students learn?

Students can find the rating, outlook, key strengths, key weaknesses and rating sensitivities in a published rating report, and explain why a credit rating is an opinion on debt, not on a company's shares.

  • What a credit rating is and who issues it
  • SEBI's standard long-term rating symbols, AAA to D
  • The parts of a rating report: rating table, key drivers, outlook, sensitivities, liquidity
  • Why the amount of debt alone does not decide a rating
  • A credit rating is not a recommendation on shares

How long does this lesson take?

One 40-minute period, run as a jigsaw in groups of three.

MinutesStepWhat happens
0–5HookShow HUL's ₹0 crore of borrowings and NTPC's ₹2,75,634 crore. Then show both ratings: Crisil AAA/Stable (reaffirmed) and CARE AAA; Stable (reaffirmed). Ask: "How can both get the top rating?" Students write a guess in Part A.
5–11What a rating isTeach the SEBI scale from Part B: AAA, AA, A and BBB, then BB, B, C and D. A rating is an agency's opinion on whether a debt will be repaid in full and on time. The company being rated pays the agency, and the rating is not a recommendation on any security.
11–25Jigsaw: one report eachIn each group of three, one student reads the Crisil extract on HUL, one the CARE extract on NTPC and one the ICRA extract on JSW Energy. Each fills a rating card in Part C: agency, date, rating, outlook, two strengths, two weaknesses, one rating sensitivity and the liquidity label.
25–33Teach your groupEach student has two minutes to tell the group what their agency said. The group answers Part D: what reasons other than the amount of debt did each agency give?
33–37Debt, not sharesWhole class: CARE names a Government of India holding below 50% as a negative factor for NTPC. Crisil names a 10% loss of market share together with an operating margin below 15% for HUL. Ask why these are about repaying debt, not about the share. Ground rule: we explain differences, we don't rank.
37–40Exit ticketStudents answer the three exit-ticket questions on the worksheet.

What do students need?

  • The student worksheet (one per student), or the student page on phones or the class projector
  • The three report extracts on the student page (one per student in each group)
  • The answer key (teacher only)
  • Optional: the slides, projected

Discussion questions

  1. CARE gives NTPC's total debt at 4.6 times its FY25 EBITDA, yet rates it AAA. Which two reasons in the report help explain that?
  2. Crisil calls HUL's dividend payout of 117% of FY25 profit a key monitorable. Why would a lender care how much a company pays to its shareholders?
  3. ICRA says about 96% of JSW Energy's operating capacity is under long-term contracts. How do long contracts help a lender?
  4. A rating sensitivity says what could lead to a change. Why is it not a forecast that the rating will change?
  5. The company pays the agency for its rating. What does the agency's report do to show its reasons in the open?

How do I adapt it for different learners?

Students still building their English
Pre-teach five words with the word bank: rating, outlook, sensitivity, liquidity and counterparty. Give each student the rating card as a table to fill, not sentences.
Students who need more support
Give students the HUL extract only, with the rating, outlook and one strength already underlined. They find one weakness and one sensitivity.
Students ready for more
ICRA names net debt above 5.5 times OPBDITA, on a sustained basis, as a downgrade metric for JSW Energy. Students find what OPBDITA means, explain "on a sustained basis" in their own words, and say why an agency writes a trigger rather than a forecast.
Extension
Students find one more company's rating in its annual report or in a credit rating disclosure filed on NSE. They note the agency, the date, the rating and the outlook, and read the rationale on the agency's website for one strength, one weakness and one sensitivity. No ranking.

Which CBSE units does it support?

We say a lesson supports a syllabus unit, never that it covers it fully. Cityfort is not affiliated with CBSE.

  • Financial Markets Management (805), Class XI, Unit 2: Primary and Secondary Market (CBSE Financial Markets Management (805)): Debt investment: debt instruments and bonds rated for their credit quality
  • Business Studies (054), Class XII, Unit 9: Financial Management (CBSE Business Studies (054)), partly: Financing decision: risk and cost of borrowed funds as factors

Which CBSE units these lessons support

Teacher background in 2 minutes

What do the rating symbols mean?

SEBI has standardised the long-term symbols. AAA means the highest degree of safety regarding timely servicing of financial obligations; then come AA, A and BBB. BB, B and C mean rising risk of default, and D means default. Plus and minus signs show standing within AA to C.

Who pays for the rating?

The company that issues the debt pays the agency, which SEBI calls the issuer-pays model. SEBI's rules require agencies to state that ratings are not recommendations to buy, hold or sell any security.

Why does NTPC hold AAA with so much debt?

CARE's report gives its reasons: long-term contracts with cost-plus tariffs, NTPC's size (89.1 GW, about 17% of India's capacity) and a 51.1% Government of India holding. It also lists weaknesses: dues from state power distributors and a capital spending plan of about ₹2,66,558 crore for FY26 to FY28.

Are the agency's ratios the same as the textbook's?

Agencies adjust the numbers their own way. Crisil put HUL's FY25 adjusted interest coverage at 58.74 times; Lesson 3's formula gives a different figure for a different year. Compare an agency's ratio only with the same agency's ratio.

Why are the dates different?

Each agency reviews a rating on its own timetable. Crisil's HUL report is dated 3 Oct 2025, CARE's NTPC report 22 May 2026 and ICRA's JSW Energy report 11 Sep 2026. Tell students to write the date on every rating card.

If your class runs a stock-market simulation, these lessons can come before it: they explain what a company does and how it reports results. They do not suggest which companies to choose, and Cityfort does not run, rank or judge simulation picks.

Where does this lesson fit in the CBSE syllabus?

It supports the debt investment session of Financial Markets Management (805) Class XI, Unit 2, which covers bonds rated for their credit quality. It supports part of Business Studies (054) Class XII Unit 9, where risk and cost of borrowed funds shape the financing decision. Which CBSE units these lessons support

Cityfort is not affiliated with, approved by or endorsed by CBSE, NCERT, NCFE, SEBI, NSE or BSE. Board and curriculum names are used only to say which published syllabus units a lesson supports.

Where do the numbers come from?

Data from Hindustan Unilever's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 2 Jun 2026; NTPC's Q2 FY27 quarterly results, filed with BSE on 31 Oct 2026; and JSW Energy's Q2 FY27 quarterly results, filed with NSE on 28 Oct 2026. Checked 16 Nov 2026. The lesson keeps these dated numbers until the next edition.

  1. S1 Integrated Annual Report 2025-26 (FY26), incl. standalone and consolidated financial statements · Hindustan Unilever Limited, filed with NSE · 2 Jun 2026
  2. S2 Rating rationale: Hindustan Unilever Ltd, long-term rating reaffirmed at Crisil AAA/Stable, Crisil A1+ assigned, 3 Oct 2025 · Crisil Ratings Ltd · 3 Oct 2025
  3. S3 Unaudited financial results Q2 FY27 (quarter ended 30 Sep 2026), standalone and consolidated (board outcome 31 Oct 2026) · NTPC Limited, filed with BSE and NSE · 31 Oct 2026
  4. S4 Press release: NTPC Limited, ratings reaffirmed (CARE AAA; Stable / CARE A1+), 22 May 2026 · CARE Ratings Ltd · 22 May 2026
  5. S5 Consolidated results XBRL Q2 FY27, incl. half-year balance sheet (integrated filing) · JSW Energy Limited, filed with NSE · 28 Oct 2026
  6. S6 ICRA rationale: JSW Energy Limited, ratings reaffirmed [ICRA]AA (Stable)/[ICRA]A1+, 11 Sep 2026 · ICRA Limited · 11 Sep 2026
  7. S7 SEBI FAQs on Credit Rating Agencies (2 Mar 2026) · SEBI · 2 Mar 2026
  8. S8 SEBI (Credit Rating Agencies) Regulations, 1999, last amended 15 Jan 2026 · SEBI · 15 Jan 2026
  9. S9 Financial Markets Management (Code 805), Skill Subject curriculum 2026–27, Class XI–XII · Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) · 13 Mar 2026
  10. S10 Business Studies (Code 054), Senior School Curriculum 2026–27 · Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) · 13 Mar 2026
  11. S11 Unaudited results Q2 FY27 (quarter and half year to 30 Sep 2026), standalone and consolidated, with board outcome and media release · JSW Energy Limited, filed with NSE · 28 Oct 2026

Questions teachers ask

Is a credit rating a view on whether to buy the shares?

A credit rating is an opinion on whether a company will repay its debt on time. SEBI's rules require agencies to say ratings are not recommendations to buy, hold or sell any security.

Where can students read the full rating reports?

On each agency's website, searched by company name: Crisil, CARE Ratings and ICRA. The student page prints the parts students need, because it links only to filings on NSE, BSE and SEBI.

Why these three companies?

Two have the same AAA rating with very different debt, and the third has an AA rating with a lot of debt. The three reports also come from three different agencies.

Some of the reports are a year old. Is that a problem?

Each report is dated, and the lesson treats it as a document of that date. Agencies review ratings regularly, so a later report may say something different; the extension asks students to check.

Does the lesson say which company is a safer borrower?

Students record what each agency wrote and why, without ranking the companies. Cityfort is not a SEBI-registered adviser and gives no advice.

Optional further reading

These pages are on the main Cityfort site, which has its own ads and cookie choice. No lesson step needs them.

How do I credit and share it?

Credit line to copy: "Debt, cash and staying power: Lesson 4 – Reading a credit rating report" by Cityfort (cityfort.in/teachers/debt-cash-and-staying-power/reading-a-credit-rating), CC BY-NC 4.0. Data from Hindustan Unilever's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 2 Jun 2026; NTPC's Q2 FY27 quarterly results, filed with BSE on 31 Oct 2026; and JSW Energy's Q2 FY27 quarterly results, filed with NSE on 28 Oct 2026.

License: CC BY-NC 4.0. If you change this material, please remove the Cityfort name or mark it as modified; changed versions are not reviewed by Cityfort.

Company names are trademarks of their owners; Cityfort is not affiliated with or endorsed by them.

Questions or corrections: contact us.

What changed (1)
  • v1.0, 16 Nov 2026: First edition (2026–27).

Last updated 16 Nov 2026.

Disclaimer

For learning only. Cityfort is not a SEBI-registered adviser and does not recommend buying or selling any security. Prices shown are dated and may be out of date.

Investing in securities involves risk, including loss of capital. Before making any investment decision, do your own research and consider consulting a SEBI-registered investment adviser.

Cityfort, its owners and contributors may or may not hold securities of companies covered. Content is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security.

Read the full disclaimer

Cityfort publishes educational content that explains how listed companies work. Cityfort is not registered with the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) as an Investment Adviser or Research Analyst and does not provide investment advice, recommendations, ratings, price targets or any opinion on whether to buy, sell or hold any security.

All information is taken from publicly available sources, mainly company filings on BSE and NSE, which are listed on each page with dates. We work to keep it accurate and correct errors publicly, but we do not guarantee that it is complete, accurate or up to date. Any market price or price-based ratio shown is dated, may be out of date by the time you read it, and is included only to explain concepts.

Statements by company management are reported as statements, with their date and source; they are not our forecasts.