Lesson 3 · 40 minutes · Class 11–12 Commerce
Standalone or consolidated? Why NTPC and Nestlé India report two profits for one quarter
Standalone or consolidated? is a free 40-minute lesson for Class 11–12 Commerce on the two sets of results a listed group files. Students find both profits in NTPC's and Nestlé India's Q2 FY27 filings and explain why one is higher at NTPC and lower at Nestlé India.
- Class
- Senior secondary, Class 11–12 (Commerce)
- Time
- One 40-minute period. Part E (the half year) can be set as homework.
- Formats
- Web page, student page, teacher guide (PDF), worksheet with exit ticket (PDF), answer key (PDF), slides (PowerPoint)
- Companies
- NTPC, Nestlé India
- Data
- Data from NTPC's Q2 FY27 quarterly results, filed with BSE on 31 Oct 2026 and Nestlé India's Q2 FY27 quarterly results, filed with NSE on 15 Oct 2026. Checked 16 Nov 2026.
- Edition
- 2026–27 first edition, v1.0
- License
- Free under CC BY-NC 4.0. No student logins.
Students start with a puzzle from one filing. NTPC reported a Q2 FY27 profit of ₹5,320 crore in one table and ₹7,351 crore in another. Both are correct.
Students learn what standalone and consolidated results cover, then explain NTPC's gap. Nestlé India shows the opposite case: its consolidated profit, ₹1,010 crore, was below its standalone profit of ₹1,027 crore.
What's included?
- PDFTeacher guide (PDF)131 KB
- PDFStudent worksheet (PDF)98 KB
- PDFAnswer key (PDF)84 KB
- PPTXSlides (PowerPoint)42 KB
Student page (no login, no answers)
cityfort.in/teachers/reading-quarterly-results/standalone-or-consolidated/student
Short link for the board: cityfort.in/class/standalone-consolidated
Share with a class or a colleague
https://cityfort.in/teachers/reading-quarterly-results/standalone-or-consolidated
What will students learn?
Students can find the standalone and consolidated figures in a real results filing, explain what each covers, and give a reason the two differ, using subsidiaries, joint ventures and minority shareholders.
- Standalone results: the listed company alone
- Consolidated results: the company and the companies it controls
- Joint ventures: one line for the company's share of profit or loss
- Profit for the period and profit for the owners: minority shareholders
- Saying which basis a number uses before comparing it
How long does this lesson take?
One 40-minute period. Part E (the half year) can be set as homework.
| Minutes | Step | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| 0–4 | Hook | Show the two NTPC profits for July–September 2026: ₹5,320 crore on PDF page 2 and ₹7,351 crore on page 11. Ask: "How can one company make two profits in the same quarter?" Students guess in Part A. |
| 4–11 | Two sets of results | Teach Part B with the made-up bakery group: the parent sells ₹100 to outsiders and ₹20 to its own café subsidiary, which sells ₹50 to outsiders. Standalone revenue is ₹120; consolidated revenue is ₹150, not ₹170, because the ₹20 inside the group is removed. (made-up numbers) |
| 11–23 | NTPC: the group is bigger | Pairs read NTPC's two tables in Part C and work out the gap: ₹7,351 crore − ₹5,320 crore = ₹2,031 crore. Of that, ₹625 crore is the share of joint ventures' profits. Then they split the group profit between NTPC's owners (₹7,030 crore) and minority shareholders (₹321 crore). |
| 23–31 | Nestlé India: the group profit is lower | Part D: Nestlé India owns 49% of a joint venture with Dr. Reddy's, which its consolidated results account for as an associate. The venture made a loss, so the line "Share of (profit)/loss of Associate" (₹17 crore, PDF page 7) took consolidated profit below standalone profit. |
| 31–37 | Which one to quote? | Whole class: a news headline says "NTPC’s Q2 profit was ₹7,351 crore". Ask which table it came from, whether it includes minority shareholders, and what a careful reader would add. Ground rule: we explain differences, we don’t rank. |
| 37–40 | Exit ticket | Students answer the three exit-ticket questions on the worksheet. |
What do students need?
- The student worksheet (one per student), or the student page on phones or the class projector
- The answer key (teacher only)
- Optional: the slides, projected
- A calculator per pair
Discussion questions
- NTPC's standalone revenue was 84.3% of its consolidated revenue. What does the other part tell you about how NTPC is organised?
- Why is a joint venture's result added as one line (₹625 crore for NTPC) instead of line by line like a subsidiary's?
- A made-up company owns 60% of a subsidiary. The consolidated statement adds all of the subsidiary’s profit, then shows the minority’s share separately. Why not add only 60% from the start?
- When you compare two companies, why must you check that both numbers are on the same basis?
- Which set of results would a lender to NTPC's parent company alone want to read? Which would someone studying the whole group want?
How do I adapt it for different learners?
- Students still building their English
- Pre-teach five words with the word bank: subsidiary, joint venture, standalone, consolidated and minority shareholders. Draw the bakery group as boxes and arrows.
- Students who need more support
- Give Part C with the subtraction already set up. Students do NTPC only and answer one Nestlé India question aloud.
- Students ready for more
- For H1 FY27, NTPC's standalone profit was ₹10,662 crore and consolidated profit for owners ₹13,751 crore. Students explain why the owners' figure, not the profit for the period, is the fairer one to set against the standalone profit.
- Extension
- Students take one more company's Q2 FY27 results filing on NSE that has both sets of results. They copy standalone and consolidated revenue and profit, with the pages, work out the gap, and find the line that names the share of joint ventures or associates. No ranking.
Which CBSE units does it support?
We say a lesson supports a syllabus unit, never that it covers it fully. Cityfort is not affiliated with CBSE.
- Accountancy (055), Class XII, Part B: Analysis of Financial Statements (CBSE Accountancy (055)), partly: Financial statements of a company: meaning, nature, uses and importance
- Business Studies (054), Class XI, Unit 3: Public, Private and Global Enterprises (CBSE Business Studies (054)), partly: Global enterprises; joint ventures
- Accountancy (055), Class XII, Project work (CBSE Accountancy (055)), partly: Financial statement analysis of a company, where students say which set of statements they use
Teacher background in 2 minutes
What does SEBI ask for?
Under Regulation 33, every listed company files standalone quarterly and year-to-date results. If it has subsidiaries, it must also file consolidated results.
How are consolidated results built?
The parent's and subsidiaries' income, costs, assets and liabilities are added line by line, and dealings between group companies are removed, so nothing is counted twice. Dividends a subsidiary pays the parent are one such dealing.
What about joint ventures?
A joint venture is shared with another owner, so it is not added line by line. NTPC's consolidated statement shows only its "share of profits/(loss) of joint ventures accounted for using equity method", ₹625 crore in Q2 FY27, as one line before tax.
What is non-controlling interest?
When a subsidiary has outside shareholders, consolidated profit belongs partly to them. NTPC's statement splits its ₹7,351 crore into ₹7,030 crore for its owners and ₹321 crore for non-controlling interest (minority shareholders).
Which basis do Cityfort pages use?
Cityfort stock pages use consolidated numbers, owners' share, unless a company has no subsidiaries that matter. Nestlé India's page uses standalone numbers for that reason and notes the consolidated profit beside them.
If your class runs a stock-market simulation, these lessons can come before it: they explain what a company does and how it reports results. They do not suggest which companies to choose, and Cityfort does not run, rank or judge simulation picks.
Where does this lesson fit in the CBSE syllabus?
It supports part of Accountancy (055) Class XII, Part B, on reading a company's financial statements, and the project work (financial statement analysis of a company), where students say which set of statements they use. It supports part of Business Studies (054) Class XI, Unit 3, where students meet joint ventures. Which CBSE units these lessons support
Cityfort is not affiliated with, approved by or endorsed by CBSE, NCERT, NCFE, SEBI, NSE or BSE. Board and curriculum names are used only to say which published syllabus units a lesson supports.
Where do the numbers come from?
Data from NTPC's Q2 FY27 quarterly results, filed with BSE on 31 Oct 2026 and Nestlé India's Q2 FY27 quarterly results, filed with NSE on 15 Oct 2026. Checked 16 Nov 2026. The lesson keeps these dated numbers until the next edition.
- S1 Unaudited financial results Q2 FY27 (quarter and six months ended 30 Sep 2026), standalone (PDF page 2) and consolidated (PDF page 11) (board outcome 31 Oct 2026) · NTPC Limited, filed with BSE and NSE · 31 Oct 2026
- S2 Unaudited financial results and press release, Q2 FY27 (quarter ended 30 Sep 2026), standalone (PDF page 2) and consolidated (PDF page 7), amounts in “₹ million” · Nestlé India Limited, filed with NSE and BSE · 15 Oct 2026
- S3 Integrated filing (consolidated, iXBRL), Q2 FY27 · Nestlé India Limited, filed with NSE · 15 Oct 2026
- S4 Annual Report 2025-26 (FY26), standalone and consolidated financial statements · Nestlé India Limited, filed with NSE · 5 Jun 2026
- S5 SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015, as amended up to 15 Oct 2026: regulation 33(3) · SEBI · 15 Oct 2026
- S6 Ind AS 110, Consolidated Financial Statements, paragraph B86 (as notified by MCA, amended to 30 Mar 2016) · ICAI, Compendium of Indian Accounting Standards 2025-26 · 30 Mar 2016
- S7 Accountancy (Code 055), Senior School Curriculum 2026–27 (dated 13 Mar 2026 by the CBSE server, checked 15 Nov 2026) · Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) · 13 Mar 2026
- S8 Business Studies (Code 054), Senior School Curriculum 2026–27 · Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) · 13 Mar 2026
Questions teachers ask
- Is consolidation in the Class 12 Accountancy syllabus?
Consolidation itself is not a syllabus topic, but listed companies' statements are consolidated, and the project work uses them. This lesson gives students only what they need to read both sets.
- Which profit should students quote?
Quote the consolidated profit attributable to owners when describing the group, and say so. When students use standalone numbers, they label them standalone.
- Why does Nestlé India's page use standalone numbers?
Nestlé India has no subsidiaries that change the picture; its consolidated results add only its share of a joint venture with Dr. Reddy's, accounted for as an associate. Its Cityfort page uses standalone numbers and notes the consolidated profit.
- Is a bigger consolidated profit a good sign?
A consolidated profit is bigger or smaller depending on how the group is organised; it is not a sign either way. The lesson asks students to explain the gap, not to judge it.
- Where in a filing are the two sets?
Usually standalone first, then consolidated, each with its own statement of assets and liabilities, cash flows and auditor's report. In NTPC's Q2 FY27 filing they start on PDF pages 2 and 11.
Optional further reading
These pages are on the main Cityfort site, which has its own ads and cookie choice. No lesson step needs them.
How do I credit and share it?
Credit line to copy: "Reading quarterly results: Lesson 3 – Standalone or consolidated? Two profits in one filing" by Cityfort (cityfort.in/teachers/reading-quarterly-results/standalone-or-consolidated), CC BY-NC 4.0. Data from NTPC's Q2 FY27 quarterly results, filed with BSE on 31 Oct 2026 and Nestlé India's Q2 FY27 quarterly results, filed with NSE on 15 Oct 2026.
License: CC BY-NC 4.0. If you change this material, please remove the Cityfort name or mark it as modified; changed versions are not reviewed by Cityfort.
Company names are trademarks of their owners; Cityfort is not affiliated with or endorsed by them.
Questions or corrections: contact us.
What changed (1)
- v1.0, 16 Nov 2026: First edition (2026–27).
Last updated 16 Nov 2026.
Disclaimer
For learning only. Cityfort is not a SEBI-registered adviser and does not recommend buying or selling any security. Prices shown are dated and may be out of date.
Investing in securities involves risk, including loss of capital. Before making any investment decision, do your own research and consider consulting a SEBI-registered investment adviser.
Cityfort, its owners and contributors may or may not hold securities of companies covered. Content is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security.
Read the full disclaimerHide the full disclaimer
Cityfort publishes educational content that explains how listed companies work. Cityfort is not registered with the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) as an Investment Adviser or Research Analyst and does not provide investment advice, recommendations, ratings, price targets or any opinion on whether to buy, sell or hold any security.
All information is taken from publicly available sources, mainly company filings on BSE and NSE, which are listed on each page with dates. We work to keep it accurate and correct errors publicly, but we do not guarantee that it is complete, accurate or up to date. Any market price or price-based ratio shown is dated, may be out of date by the time you read it, and is included only to explain concepts.
Statements by company management are reported as statements, with their date and source; they are not our forecasts.