Lesson 3 · 40 minutes · Class 11–12 Commerce
Four traps that make a comparison unfair, with real Indian filings
Four traps is a free 40-minute Class 11–12 Commerce lesson on comparisons that look fair but are not. Groups work through DMart, ABB India and Hitachi Energy India, Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles, and HDFC Bank against Maruti Suzuki.
- Class
- Senior secondary, Class 11–12 (Commerce)
- Time
- One 40-minute period, run as four stations. With a second period, every group can do every station.
- Formats
- Web page, student page, teacher guide (PDF), worksheet with exit ticket (PDF), answer key (PDF), slides (PowerPoint)
- Companies
- DMart, ABB India, Hitachi Energy India, Tata Motors PV, HDFC Bank, Maruti Suzuki
- Data
- Data from DMart's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 23 Jul 2026; ABB India's CY25 annual report, filed with NSE on 9 Apr 2026; Hitachi Energy India's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 31 Jul 2026; Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 15 Jun 2026; HDFC Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 11 Jul 2026; and Maruti Suzuki's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 8 Aug 2026. Checked 15 Nov 2026.
- Edition
- 2026–27 first edition, v1.0
- License
- Free under CC BY-NC 4.0. No student logins.
Lesson 1 gave three rules for a fair comparison. This lesson shows four real cases where a comparison looks fair and is not, and adds a fourth rule: the same business in both years.
Groups take one station card each, find the trap and rewrite an unfair sentence so it keeps the rules. Then each group teaches its trap to the class.
What's included?
- PDFTeacher guide (PDF)161 KB
- PDFStudent worksheet (PDF)163 KB
- PDFAnswer key (PDF)120 KB
- PPTXSlides (PowerPoint)49 KB
Student page (no login, no answers)
cityfort.in/teachers/comparing-companies-fairly/four-comparison-traps/student
Short link for the board: cityfort.in/class/compare-traps
Share with a class or a colleague
https://cityfort.in/teachers/comparing-companies-fairly/four-comparison-traps
What will students learn?
Students can spot four reasons two numbers do not compare: standalone against consolidated, years covering different months, a demerger that changes the business, and a bank against a manufacturer. They can rewrite an unfair comparison so it keeps the rules.
- Standalone and consolidated financial statements
- Calendar-year and April–March financial years
- Re-presented figures after a demerger
- Why a bank's income and margins differ from a manufacturer's
How long does this lesson take?
One 40-minute period, run as four stations. With a second period, every group can do every station.
| Minutes | Step | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| 0–5 | Hook | Project the unfair sentence: "Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles' revenue fell -23.7% in FY26." Ask: what would you check before you repeat it? Students write one check in Part A. |
| 5–8 | Four rules | Recall the three rules from Lesson 1: same year, same measure, same kind of statement. Add the fourth: the same business in both years. |
| 8–22 | Stations | Four groups, one station each: standalone or consolidated (DMart), different calendars (ABB India and Hitachi Energy India), a demerger (Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles), a bank against a carmaker (HDFC Bank and Maruti Suzuki). Each group answers its station's questions and rewrites its unfair sentence. |
| 22–34 | Teach your trap | Each group has three minutes: the trap, the rule it breaks and its fair sentence. Other students note each trap in Part F. |
| 34–37 | Back to the hook | Return to the Tata Motors sentence. The fair comparison uses FY25 re-presented, so revenue fell -8.3%, not -23.7%. |
| 37–40 | Exit ticket | Students answer the three exit-ticket questions on the worksheet. |
What do students need?
- The student worksheet (one per student): each group uses its own station page
- The answer key (teacher only)
- Optional: the slides, projected, and the four station pages printed as separate cards
What numbers does the lesson use?
Each receipt shows where each ₹100 that came in went in one financial year, from the company's annual report or results filed with the stock exchanges.
| Line | Per ₹100 that came in |
|---|---|
| Interest paid to depositors | ₹37.4 |
| Interest paid on borrowings | ₹10.9 |
| Employees | ₹7.0 |
| Other running costs | ₹12.6 |
| Provisions for bad loans and other risks | ₹6.3 |
| Tax | ₹5.5 |
| Kept as profit | ₹20.2 |
| Total | ₹99.9 |
Source: HDFC Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 11 Jul 2026; standalone profit and loss account, HDFC Bank alone (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ interest earned plus other income × 100). Lines are rounded to the nearest 10 paise, so the total may differ from ₹100 by a few paise.
| Line | Per ₹100 that came in |
|---|---|
| Materials, parts and goods bought | ₹70.5 |
| Employees | ₹4.8 |
| Royalty to Suzuki Motor Corporation | ₹2.9 |
| Other running costs | ₹7.9 |
| Depreciation and interest | ₹3.7 |
| Income tax | ₹2.4 |
| Kept as profit | ₹7.8 |
| Total | ₹100.0 |
Source: Maruti Suzuki's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 8 Aug 2026; consolidated statement of profit and loss (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ revenue, other income and share of part-owned companies' profit × 100).
Discussion questions
- DMart's stores company earned ₹3,224 crore in FY26, more than the group's ₹2,970 crore. How can a group earn less than one of its own companies?
- ABB India's year ends in December and Hitachi Energy India's in March. Both companies call their first quarter "Q1". Why is that a trap?
- Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles reported ₹82,390 crore of profit for owners in FY26, but the continuing business made a loss. What should a fair sentence about FY26 profit say?
- HDFC Bank kept ₹20.2 of every ₹100 that came in, Maruti ₹7.8. What does the bank's biggest line, interest paid to depositors, tell you about why these two numbers do not compare?
- Which of the four traps would be easiest to miss in a newspaper headline? Why?
How do I adapt it for different learners?
- Students still building their English
- Give each group the word bank for its station only: standalone and consolidated; calendar year and financial year; demerger and re-presented; deposits and advances. Groups can report with the sentence frames.
- Students who need more support
- Give the Station 4 (bank) card, which needs reading more than arithmetic. Read the card's first paragraph aloud and let students answer with the line names.
- Students ready for more
- Students do Station 1 for HDFC Bank as well: the bank alone made ₹74,671 crore and the group ₹76,026 crore. Why is HDFC Bank's group profit above the bank's, when DMart's is below?
- Extension
- Students find one more company page on Cityfort with a calendar year (CY), a demerger note or a standalone basis, and write one unfair and one fair sentence about it, naming the filing and the period.
Which CBSE units does it support?
We say a lesson supports a syllabus unit, never that it covers it fully. Cityfort is not affiliated with CBSE.
- Accountancy (055), Class XII, Part B: Analysis of Financial Statements (CBSE Accountancy (055)), partly: Financial statements of a company; limitations of financial statement analysis
- Accountancy (055), Class XII, Project work (CBSE Accountancy (055)): Project aspect: comparative and common-size statements
- Financial Markets Management (805), Class XII, Unit 4 (CBSE Financial Markets Management (805)), partly: Financial statement analysis
Teacher background in 2 minutes
Standalone or consolidated?
Standalone statements cover the listed company alone. Consolidated statements add its subsidiaries and remove sales between group companies. A subsidiary's loss lowers group profit, so consolidated profit can sit below standalone profit.
Which Indian companies use a calendar year?
Most Indian companies report April to March. Some with foreign parents report January to December, such as ABB India, and label the year CY25. Hitachi Energy India moved from a December year end to March, so its FY22 ran 15 months.
What does re-presented mean?
After a demerger, a company shows the business it kept as "continuing operations" and re-presents the previous year on the same basis. The new annual report's previous-year column then differs from the old annual report. Always take both years from the same report.
Why does a bank's receipt look so different?
A bank's main cost is the interest it pays depositors, and its income is the interest it earns on loans. Its size shows in its loans and deposits, which are many times its yearly income. Banks are read with their own measures: net interest margin, bad loans (NPAs) and capital.
Why is HDFC Bank's receipt for the bank alone?
Cityfort's HDFC Bank receipt uses the standalone accounts, while the page's yearly numbers are consolidated and include its insurance and lending subsidiaries. The receipt's note says so. This is Station 1's trap inside Station 4.
If your class runs a stock-market simulation, these lessons can come before it: they explain what a company does and how it reports results. They do not suggest which companies to choose, and Cityfort does not run, rank or judge simulation picks.
Which rule does each trap break?
Each station breaks one of four rules. Keep the four rules on the board for the rest of the unit.
- Same kind of statement: standalone against standalone, or consolidated against consolidated (Station 1, DMart).
- Same year: both numbers cover the same months (Station 2, ABB India and Hitachi Energy India).
- Same business: both years cover the same business, taken from the same annual report (Station 3, Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles).
- Same measure: the measure means the same thing for both companies (Station 4, HDFC Bank and Maruti Suzuki).
Where does this lesson fit in the CBSE syllabus?
It supports Analysis of Financial Statements in Accountancy (055) Class XII, Part B (Unit 3 in the marks table, Unit 4 in the detailed syllabus): students meet the limits of comparing statements, using real ones. It supports the project aspect "comparative and common-size statements" by showing what to check before comparing. Which CBSE units these lessons support
Cityfort is not affiliated with, approved by or endorsed by CBSE, NCERT, NCFE, SEBI, NSE or BSE. Board and curriculum names are used only to say which published syllabus units a lesson supports.
Where do the numbers come from?
Data from DMart's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 23 Jul 2026; ABB India's CY25 annual report, filed with NSE on 9 Apr 2026; Hitachi Energy India's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 31 Jul 2026; Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 15 Jun 2026; HDFC Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 11 Jul 2026; and Maruti Suzuki's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 8 Aug 2026. Checked 15 Nov 2026. The lesson keeps these dated numbers until the next edition.
- S1 Annual Report FY26, with standalone and consolidated financial statements · Avenue Supermarts Limited (DMart), filed with NSE · 23 Jul 2026
- S2 Q4 FY26 and FY26 standalone financial results (XBRL) · Avenue Supermarts Limited (DMart), filed with NSE · 2 May 2026
- S3 Q4 FY26 and FY26 consolidated financial results (XBRL) · Avenue Supermarts Limited (DMart), filed with NSE · 2 May 2026
- S4 Integrated Annual Report 2025 (year ended 31 Dec 2025), with standalone financial statements · ABB India Limited, filed with NSE · 9 Apr 2026
- S5 Unaudited results, quarter ended 30 Jun 2025 (Q2 CY25) · ABB India Limited, filed with NSE · 2 Aug 2025
- S6 Unaudited results, quarter ended 30 Sep 2025 (Q3 CY25) · ABB India Limited, filed with NSE · 6 Nov 2025
- S7 Audited results (XBRL), quarter and year ended 31 Dec 2025 (Q4 CY25) · ABB India Limited, filed with NSE · 19 Feb 2026
- S8 Integrated Annual Report 2025-26 (FY26, April 2025 to March 2026), with standalone financial statements · Hitachi Energy India Limited, filed with NSE · 31 Jul 2026
- S9 Unaudited results, quarter ended 30 Jun 2025 (Q1 FY26) · Hitachi Energy India Limited, filed with NSE · 30 Jul 2025
- S10 Unaudited results, quarter ended 30 Sep 2025 (Q2 FY26) · Hitachi Energy India Limited, filed with NSE · 3 Nov 2025
- S11 Unaudited results, quarter ended 31 Dec 2025 (Q3 FY26) · Hitachi Energy India Limited, filed with NSE · 5 Feb 2026
- S12 81st Integrated Annual Report 2025-26 (FY26), with consolidated financial statements (FY25 re-presented) · Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles Limited, filed with NSE · 15 Jun 2026
- S13 80th Integrated Annual Report 2024-25 (FY25), with consolidated financial statements including the commercial vehicles business · Tata Motors Limited (now Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles Limited), filed with NSE · 24 May 2025
- S14 Integrated Annual Report FY26 (2025-26), with standalone and consolidated financial statements · HDFC Bank Limited, filed with NSE · 11 Jul 2026
- S15 Annual Integrated Report FY26 (2025-26), with consolidated financial statements · Maruti Suzuki India Limited, filed with NSE · 8 Aug 2026
Questions teachers ask
- Can I run it without stations?
Run it as four whole-class rounds of eight minutes each, with the slides. Students then fill in Part F as you go, and the exit ticket stays the same.
- What if a group finishes early?
Send it to the advanced question on HDFC Bank, or to the extension. Station 4 takes the least arithmetic, so give it to a group that needs more time to read.
- Is the lesson saying a calendar-year company is less reliable?
The lesson treats a calendar year as a different set of months, nothing more. ABB India's accounts are as complete as Hitachi Energy India's; they cover different months.
- Why use a bank in an Accountancy lesson?
A bank's accounts follow a different format. HDFC Bank's are drawn up under the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (Third Schedule) and RBI directions. Students who compare a bank with a manufacturer for the project need to know that the lines do not match.
- Does the lesson judge Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles' loss?
The lesson only shows which numbers compare. It does not judge the loss or the company's shares, and Cityfort is not a SEBI-registered adviser.
Optional further reading
These pages are on the main Cityfort site, which has its own ads and cookie choice. No lesson step needs them.
How do I credit and share it?
Credit line to copy: "Comparing two companies fairly: Lesson 3 – Four traps that make a comparison unfair" by Cityfort (cityfort.in/teachers/comparing-companies-fairly/four-comparison-traps), CC BY-NC 4.0. Data from DMart's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 23 Jul 2026; ABB India's CY25 annual report, filed with NSE on 9 Apr 2026; Hitachi Energy India's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 31 Jul 2026; Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 15 Jun 2026; HDFC Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 11 Jul 2026; and Maruti Suzuki's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 8 Aug 2026.
License: CC BY-NC 4.0. If you change this material, please remove the Cityfort name or mark it as modified; changed versions are not reviewed by Cityfort.
Company names are trademarks of their owners; Cityfort is not affiliated with or endorsed by them.
Questions or corrections: contact us.
What changed (1)
- v1.0, 15 Nov 2026: First edition (2026–27).
Last updated 15 Nov 2026.
Disclaimer
For learning only. Cityfort is not a SEBI-registered adviser and does not recommend buying or selling any security. Prices shown are dated and may be out of date.
Investing in securities involves risk, including loss of capital. Before making any investment decision, do your own research and consider consulting a SEBI-registered investment adviser.
Cityfort, its owners and contributors may or may not hold securities of companies covered. Content is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security.
Read the full disclaimerHide the full disclaimer
Cityfort publishes educational content that explains how listed companies work. Cityfort is not registered with the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) as an Investment Adviser or Research Analyst and does not provide investment advice, recommendations, ratings, price targets or any opinion on whether to buy, sell or hold any security.
All information is taken from publicly available sources, mainly company filings on BSE and NSE, which are listed on each page with dates. We work to keep it accurate and correct errors publicly, but we do not guarantee that it is complete, accurate or up to date. Any market price or price-based ratio shown is dated, may be out of date by the time you read it, and is included only to explain concepts.
Statements by company management are reported as statements, with their date and source; they are not our forecasts.