Skip to content
New: 30 more Indian companies explained, from Ather and Pine Labs to IDBI Bank

Project (optional) · Class 11–12 Commerce

Class 12 Accountancy project: a fair comparison of two listed companies

This free project asks Class 12 students to compare two listed companies fairly, using their FY26 annual reports. Students build comparative and common-size statements and the net profit ratio, then write a comparison with no verdict.

For learning only. Cityfort is not a SEBI-registered adviser and does not recommend buying or selling any security. Prices shown are dated and may be out of date.

Class
Senior secondary, Class 11–12 (Commerce)
Time
Three 40-minute periods in class, or two periods plus homework.
Formats
Web page, student page, teacher guide (PDF), worksheet with exit ticket (PDF), answer key (PDF), slides (PowerPoint)
Companies
Hindustan Unilever, ITC, DMart, Trent, Infosys, TCS, HDFC Bank, ICICI Bank
Data
Data from Hindustan Unilever's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 2 Jun 2026; ITC's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 26 Jun 2026; DMart's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 23 Jul 2026; Trent's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 30 May 2026; Infosys's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 30 May 2026; TCS's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 15 May 2026; HDFC Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 11 Jul 2026; ICICI Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 18 Jul 2026; Hyundai Motor India's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 3 Aug 2026; and Maruti Suzuki's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 8 Aug 2026. Checked 15 Nov 2026.
Edition
2026–27 first edition, v1.0
License
Free under CC BY-NC 4.0. No student logins.

Each student, or pair of students, takes one pair of companies from the same industry and writes a fair comparison of them from their FY26 annual reports. The guide gives four pair cards with every starting number, a planner, a worked example and a rubric.

The project covers two of the Accountancy project aspects: comparative and common-size statements, and accounting ratios (the net profit ratio). Each pair hides one trap from Lesson 3, and finding it is part of the marks. No marks depend on which pair a student takes.

What's included?

Student page (no login, no answers)

cityfort.in/teachers/comparing-companies-fairly/fair-comparison-project/student

Short link for the board: cityfort.in/class/fair-compare

Share with a class or a colleague

https://cityfort.in/teachers/comparing-companies-fairly/fair-comparison-project

What will students learn?

Students can compare two companies in one industry on two project aspects: comparative and common-size statements, and the net profit ratio. They cite every number to its filing, spot the trap in their pair and write a comparison that explains differences without ranking the companies.

  • Financial statement analysis of two listed companies
  • Comparative and common-size statements
  • Net profit ratio from real statements
  • Checking a comparison for year, basis and one-off items
  • Citing every number to its source

How long does this lesson take?

Three 40-minute periods in class, or two periods plus homework.

MinutesStepWhat happens
0–40Period 1: choose and calculateRead the worked example together. Students choose a pair, fill in Part A of the planner and work out the comparative changes (Part B) and the net profit ratios (Part C) from their card.
40–80Period 2: receipts, trap and one more factStudents compare two lines of their pair's receipts (Part D). They find their pair's trap and say how it changes the comparison (Part E), then find one more fact in an annual report, with its page (Part F).
80–120Period 3: write and checkStudents write the comparison (Part G), then swap with a partner who checks three numbers and scores the draft with the rubric (Part H). Students fix what the partner found.

What do students need?

  • The project planner (one per student): the worksheet for this lesson
  • The student page, with the four pair cards and the eight ₹100 receipts
  • The two FY26 annual reports for the student's pair, from nseindia.com (linked on each card)
  • The rubric from this page, shared with students before they start
  • A calculator

What numbers does the lesson use?

Each receipt shows where each ₹100 that came in went in one financial year, from the company's annual report or results filed with the stock exchanges.

Where each ₹100 went: Hindustan Unilever, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Materials and goods bought₹48.6
Advertising and promotion₹9.6
Other running costs, incl. fees to Unilever₹12.7
Employees₹4.9
Depreciation, interest and net one-off charges₹3.1
Tax₹4.8
Kept as profit for HUL shareholders₹16.3
Total₹100.0

Source: Hindustan Unilever's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 2 Jun 2026; consolidated statement of profit and loss, continuing business (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ revenue plus other income × 100).

Where each ₹100 went: ITC, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Materials and goods bought₹35.1
Excise duty₹11.9
Other running costs₹13.2
Employee costs₹7.3
Depreciation, interest, one-offs and minority share₹2.6
Income tax₹7.6
Kept as profit for ITC shareholders₹22.3
Total₹100.0

Source: ITC's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 26 Jun 2026; consolidated statement of profit and loss (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ revenue, other income and share of part-owned companies' profit × 100).

Where each ₹100 went: DMart, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Goods bought for sale₹84.9
Employees₹2.2
Other running costs₹5.3
Depreciation₹1.5
Interest₹0.2
Income tax₹1.6
Kept as profit for shareholders₹4.3
Total₹100.0

Source: DMart's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 23 Jul 2026; consolidated results for the year (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ revenue plus other income × 100).

Where each ₹100 went: Trent, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Goods bought for resale₹55.8
Store occupancy, including some rent₹7.7
Other running costs₹11.0
Employees₹6.7
Depreciation, interest and one-offs₹7.7
Income tax₹2.6
Kept as profit for Trent shareholders₹8.5
Total₹100.0

Source: Trent's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 30 May 2026; consolidated statement of profit and loss (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ revenue plus other income × 100).

Where each ₹100 went: Infosys, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Employees₹52.0
Subcontractors₹8.4
Software packages and bought-in items₹8.6
Travel, communication and other costs₹5.5
Depreciation₹2.7
Lease interest, tax and one-off charge₹6.7
Kept as profit₹16.1
Total₹100.0

Source: Infosys's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 30 May 2026; consolidated statement of profit and loss (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ revenue plus other income × 100).

Where each ₹100 went: TCS, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Staff pay and benefits₹57.1
Outside consultants (subcontractors)₹5.4
Offices, travel, resold hardware and other costs₹9.2
Depreciation₹2.0
Interest and tax₹6.4
One-off charges₹1.7
Kept as profit for TCS shareholders₹18.1
Profit belonging to minority partners₹0.1
Total₹100.0

Source: TCS's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 15 May 2026; consolidated statement of profit and loss (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ revenue plus other income × 100).

Where each ₹100 went: HDFC Bank, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Interest paid to depositors₹37.4
Interest paid on borrowings₹10.9
Employees₹7.0
Other running costs₹12.6
Provisions for bad loans and other risks₹6.3
Tax₹5.5
Kept as profit₹20.2
Total₹99.9

Source: HDFC Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 11 Jul 2026; standalone profit and loss account, HDFC Bank alone (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ interest earned plus other income × 100). Lines are rounded to the nearest 10 paise, so the total may differ from ₹100 by a few paise.

Where each ₹100 went: ICICI Bank, FY26
LinePer ₹100 that came in
Interest paid to depositors and lenders₹40.8
Employees₹9.0
Other running costs₹14.6
Provisions for bad loans and other risks₹2.7
Tax₹8.0
Kept as profit₹25.0
Total₹100.1

Source: ICICI Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 18 Jul 2026; standalone profit and loss account, ICICI Bank alone (Cityfort calculation: each line ÷ interest earned plus other income × 100). Lines are rounded to the nearest 10 paise, so the total may differ from ₹100 by a few paise.

Discussion questions

  1. Why does the project give no marks for the pair you choose?
  2. Which trap in the four pair cards changed a result the most? Why?
  3. What is the difference between explaining why two numbers differ and saying which company is ahead?
  4. What can your two aspects not tell you about either company?

How do I adapt it for different learners?

Students still building their English
Give students the sentence frames and the word bank, and let them write Part G as six to eight short sentences, one fact each. They may draft in a mix of English and their home language, then write the final copy in English.
Students who need more support
Give students the DMart and Trent card, which has round numbers and one trap. They work out the comparative changes for revenue only, and one net profit ratio for each company.
Students ready for more
Students add one balance-sheet fact for both companies from the annual reports, such as borrowings or cash on 31 Mar 2026, with its date, and explain it without ranking. Or they take the bank pair and explain why the net profit ratio means something different for a bank.
Extension
Students add a third company from the same industry with a Cityfort page and extend their comparison on one aspect only, naming the year, the basis and the filing for every number.

Which CBSE units does it support?

We say a lesson supports a syllabus unit, never that it covers it fully. Cityfort is not affiliated with CBSE.

  • Accountancy (055), Class XII, Project work (CBSE Accountancy (055)): One specific project based on financial statement analysis of a company covering any two aspects
  • Accountancy (055), Class XII, Part B: Analysis of Financial Statements (CBSE Accountancy (055)), partly: Comparative and common-size statements; accounting ratios (net profit ratio)
  • Financial Markets Management (805), Class XII, Unit 4 (CBSE Financial Markets Management (805)), partly: Financial statement analysis

Which CBSE units these lessons support

Teacher background in 2 minutes

What does the CBSE brief ask for?

"One specific project based on financial statement analysis of a company covering any two aspects" (CBSE Accountancy curriculum 2026–27). This project covers two of the listed aspects for two companies: comparative and common-size statements, and accounting ratios.

Why are the pairs fixed?

Each pair is a built Cityfort compare page with both companies' FY26 pages published, so the teacher can check every starting number in one place. Each pair also carries one trap from Lesson 3.

Which statements does the project use?

The yearly numbers on each card are consolidated. The two banks' receipts are for each bank alone (standalone), as their Cityfort pages say; that is part of the bank pair's trap.

Why is the net profit ratio different from the receipt's last line?

The net profit ratio divides net profit by revenue from operations (or a bank's total income). The receipt divides by all the money that came in, including other income, and uses each company's own statement. The two are close but not the same.

If your class runs a stock-market simulation, these lessons can come before it: they explain what a company does and how it reports results. They do not suggest which companies to choose, and Cityfort does not run, rank or judge simulation picks.

Which pairs can students choose?

Four pairs, each with a card on the student page and a compare page on Cityfort: Hindustan Unilever and ITC, DMart and Trent, Infosys and TCS, and HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank. The worked example uses Hyundai Motor India and Maruti Suzuki from Lessons 1 and 4.

Each pair hides one trap: one-off demerger gains in different years (Hindustan Unilever and ITC), owned stores against leased stores (DMart and Trent), receipt lines grouped differently (Infosys and TCS), and group income that includes insurance against receipts for the bank alone (HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank).

How is it marked?

The rubric has four criteria of 5 points each, 20 in all, to match the 20 marks of the Accountancy project. Map the points to your school's marking scheme.

CriterionWhat a full answer hasPoints
AccuracyEvery number matches the card or the annual report; every change and ratio is worked out correctly, with its working shown5
SourcingEvery number names its company, year, basis (standalone or consolidated) and filing; the extra fact in Part F has its page5
ClarityA classmate could explain how the two businesses differ after reading it; the pair's trap is found and explained5
NeutralityDescribes and explains, with no verdict, ranking, prediction or advice; each slip takes off a point5

No points for which pair a student chooses, and no part asks which company is ahead or for a view on either company's shares. If a project says whether to buy, sell or hold the shares, remove that part and take a point off Neutrality.

What does a worked example look like?

Hyundai Motor India and Maruti Suzuki, FY26, both consolidated: "Both carmakers spent about the same share of each ₹100 on materials: ₹70.4 at Hyundai and ₹70.5 at Maruti. Hyundai's revenue rose 2.3% from FY25 while its profit for the year changed by -3.7%, because its total expenses grew faster than its total income."

Why it is fair: both numbers are for FY26, both use the same base, both are consolidated, and it explains a difference with a reason from the statement instead of saying which company is ahead.

Where does this project fit in the CBSE syllabus?

It supports the Accountancy (055) Class XII project work, covering two aspects: comparative and common-size statements, and accounting ratios (net profit ratio). It also supports parts of Analysis of Financial Statements and of Financial Markets Management (805) Class XII, Unit 4. Which CBSE units these lessons support

Cityfort is not affiliated with, approved by or endorsed by CBSE, NCERT, NCFE, SEBI, NSE or BSE. Board and curriculum names are used only to say which published syllabus units a lesson supports.

How do I stop copied projects?

Every student writes Part F from an annual report, with its page, so no two projects are the same. Ask students to show you that fact on the page.

With a large class, give each pair of companies to no more than a quarter of the students, and keep the partner check in class.

Where do the numbers come from?

Data from Hindustan Unilever's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 2 Jun 2026; ITC's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 26 Jun 2026; DMart's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 23 Jul 2026; Trent's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 30 May 2026; Infosys's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 30 May 2026; TCS's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 15 May 2026; HDFC Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 11 Jul 2026; ICICI Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 18 Jul 2026; Hyundai Motor India's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 3 Aug 2026; and Maruti Suzuki's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 8 Aug 2026. Checked 15 Nov 2026. The lesson keeps these dated numbers until the next edition.

  1. S1 Integrated Annual Report 2025-26 (FY26), with standalone and consolidated financial statements · Hindustan Unilever Limited, filed with NSE · 2 Jun 2026
  2. S2 Report and Accounts 2026 (FY26), with standalone and consolidated financial statements · ITC Limited, filed with NSE · 26 Jun 2026
  3. S3 Annual Report FY26, with standalone and consolidated financial statements · Avenue Supermarts Limited (DMart), filed with NSE · 23 Jul 2026
  4. S4 Integrated Annual Report FY26 (2025-26), with consolidated financial statements · Trent Limited, filed with NSE · 30 May 2026
  5. S5 Integrated Annual Report FY26, with consolidated financial statements · Infosys Limited, filed with NSE · 30 May 2026
  6. S6 Integrated Annual Report FY26, with consolidated financial statements · Tata Consultancy Services Limited (TCS), filed with NSE · 15 May 2026
  7. S7 Integrated Annual Report FY26 (2025-26), with standalone and consolidated financial statements · HDFC Bank Limited, filed with NSE · 11 Jul 2026
  8. S8 Annual Report FY26 (2025-26), with standalone and consolidated financial statements · ICICI Bank Limited, filed with NSE · 18 Jul 2026
  9. S9 Annual Report 2025-26 (FY26), with audited consolidated financial statements · Hyundai Motor India Limited, filed with NSE · 3 Aug 2026
  10. S10 Annual Integrated Report FY26 (2025-26), incl. consolidated financial statements · Maruti Suzuki India Limited, filed with NSE · 8 Aug 2026
  11. S11 Accountancy (Code 055), Senior School Curriculum 2026–27 · Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) · 13 Mar 2026
  12. S12 ICRA rationale: Avenue Supermarts Limited, ratings reaffirmed, commercial paper limit enhanced (9 Oct 2026) · ICRA Limited · 9 Oct 2026

Questions teachers ask

Does this replace the Unit 1 project?

It is a second option. The Unit 1 project analyses one company on any two aspects; this one compares two companies on two set aspects, with the traps from Lesson 3.

Can students choose their own pair of companies?

Students may choose any pair with a built compare page on Cityfort if the teacher agrees. The four cards make checking quicker, because every starting number is printed.

Why is there a bank pair?

Banks report total income instead of revenue and use different measures, so the bank pair tests whether a student can keep a comparison inside one kind of business. It suits students who finished Lesson 3's bank station.

Do students need the annual reports?

The cards give every starting number. Students open one annual report for Part F, the extra fact with its page, and may check any card number against it.

Can students say which company did well?

Students describe and explain differences. The rubric gives no points for a verdict or an investment view, and Cityfort is not a SEBI-registered adviser.

Optional further reading

These pages are on the main Cityfort site, which has its own ads and cookie choice. No lesson step needs them.

How do I credit and share it?

Credit line to copy: "Comparing two companies fairly: Project – Project: a fair comparison of two companies" by Cityfort (cityfort.in/teachers/comparing-companies-fairly/fair-comparison-project), CC BY-NC 4.0. Data from Hindustan Unilever's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 2 Jun 2026; ITC's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 26 Jun 2026; DMart's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 23 Jul 2026; Trent's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 30 May 2026; Infosys's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 30 May 2026; TCS's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 15 May 2026; HDFC Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 11 Jul 2026; ICICI Bank's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 18 Jul 2026; Hyundai Motor India's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 3 Aug 2026; and Maruti Suzuki's FY26 annual report, filed with NSE on 8 Aug 2026.

License: CC BY-NC 4.0. If you change this material, please remove the Cityfort name or mark it as modified; changed versions are not reviewed by Cityfort.

Company names are trademarks of their owners; Cityfort is not affiliated with or endorsed by them.

Questions or corrections: contact us.

What changed (1)
  • v1.0, 15 Nov 2026: First edition (2026–27).

Last updated 15 Nov 2026.

Disclaimer

For learning only. Cityfort is not a SEBI-registered adviser and does not recommend buying or selling any security. Prices shown are dated and may be out of date.

Investing in securities involves risk, including loss of capital. Before making any investment decision, do your own research and consider consulting a SEBI-registered investment adviser.

Cityfort, its owners and contributors may or may not hold securities of companies covered. Content is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security.

Read the full disclaimer

Cityfort publishes educational content that explains how listed companies work. Cityfort is not registered with the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) as an Investment Adviser or Research Analyst and does not provide investment advice, recommendations, ratings, price targets or any opinion on whether to buy, sell or hold any security.

All information is taken from publicly available sources, mainly company filings on BSE and NSE, which are listed on each page with dates. We work to keep it accurate and correct errors publicly, but we do not guarantee that it is complete, accurate or up to date. Any market price or price-based ratio shown is dated, may be out of date by the time you read it, and is included only to explain concepts.

Statements by company management are reported as statements, with their date and source; they are not our forecasts.